Skip to content
Why the Right Walleye Lure Changes Everything
Want to reel in more walleye this season? You’re not alone—these elusive predators are prized for both sport and taste. But here’s the secret: success often comes down to using the best walleye baits and lures. Baits like leeches and night crawlers. Lures like jigs and spinner rigs.
In fact, according to top anglers, using a proven walleye lure can increase your catch rate by up to 60% compared to generic options. That’s huge! I’ve been chasing walleye across lakes and rivers for years, and in this guide, I’m breaking down the top-performing lures and baits that always find a spot in my tackle box.
From tried-and-true classics to high-tech designs, we’ll explore which ones work best in various conditions—so you’re never left guessing again. Let’s dive in!
What Makes a Great Walleye Lure or Bait?
Alright, so I’ve spent more hours than I care to admit out on the lake chasing after walleye—and I can tell you right now, not all lures are created equal. I’ve had days where I was sure I had the perfect setup, only to get completely skunked, and other times when I threw something random on the line and ended up with a full stringer by lunch. Point is: picking the right lure or bait for walleye isn’t just about luck. It’s about understanding a few key traits and reading the conditions like a seasoned detective.
Key traits to look for: action, color, size, depth
First off, if your lure doesn’t have the right action, you might as well be jigging with a paperclip. Walleye are picky, especially in colder months when they’re sluggish. I lean hard on slow, subtle actions—think a soft paddle tail on a jig head or a floating crankbait with a tight wobble.
Color? That’s a rabbit hole. I used to buy every color on the rack (rookie mistake). These days I stick to naturals—white, silver, perch, and occasionally firetiger when the water’s stained. If I’m fishing deep or low-light, I’ll go with something with a bit of chartreuse or glow.
Size and depth go hand in hand. In spring, I downsize—small jigs, lighter rigs. But when summer hits and they move deeper, I up my game. I’ve caught some monsters bouncing ¾ oz, jigging raps in 30 feet of water. Don’t be afraid to switch things up.
How water clarity and temperature affect lure choice
Clarity matters more than I ever expected. In clear water, I go with finesse baits—live minnows on a plain hook or something like a Lindy rig. But if the water’s stained or it’s after a storm, I’ll switch to something flashier—spinners, rattling crankbaits, or bright, soft plastics.
Temperature’s another sneaky factor. When the water’s under 50°F, I fish slow. Think live bait, dragging jigs, or vertical presentations. Over 60°F, I’ll start speeding up—trolling with crankbaits or drifting with spinner rigs. Knowing that switch is what took me from “lucky sometimes” to actually consistent.
Differences between natural vs artificial baits
Look, I’ll always have a soft spot for live minnows. Especially in early spring or fall, there’s just no beating a fathead on a jig. But I’ve also learned that artificial baits save me time and money, and they work better than I expected. Gulp! Minnows? Game changer.
That said, I treat artificials differently. They require more movement, more presentation effort. With live bait, I can let it sit. With plastics, I’ve gotta keep it dancing. If you’re just starting out, try both. But don’t assume live bait is always better—it’s not, especially when walleye are more aggressive.
Why presentation and retrieval style matter
I can’t count how many fish I’ve missed because I was retrieving too fast—or too slow. Walleye can be moody, and sometimes, just a change in your jig cadence is all it takes. One day, I was jigging in 20 feet and getting nothing. I switched to a lift-drop-pause rhythm instead of my usual drag-and-bounce, and bam—fish on.
When trolling, I mess with speed constantly. Sometimes, 1.5 mph is too slow; sometimes, 2.5 mph blows right past the bite zone. Watch your sonar; feel your lure. Presentation isn’t just what you throw—it’s how you throw it and what you do after it hits the water.
Long story short? The best walleye lure is the one that matches what the fish want that day. It’s part science, part intuition, and a whole lot of trial and error. But man, when you figure it out and feel that first thump on the line—it’s magic.
Jigs – The Classic Walleye Slayer
If there’s one lure that’s never left my tackle box, it’s the humble jig. Seriously, I could probably walleye fish for an entire season with just a handful of jig heads and do just fine. They’re simple, versatile, and for some reason, walleyes just can’t resist ’em when you use ’em right. I used to overlook jigs when I first started out—thought they were too basic. But man, I was wrong. They’ve outfished everything else I own more times than I can count.
Why jigs are effective in almost all conditions
The thing that makes jigs so dang effective is how much control you have. You can fish ’em shallow, deep, vertically, casting, dragging, snapping—you name it. Whether I’m fishing spring rivers during spawn or bouncing rock piles mid-summer, a jig can get the job done.
Another big plus? You can match them with anything. I’ve tipped jigs with leeches, minnows, crawlers, curly-tail grubs, swimbaits—heck, even a piece of gulp when I ran out of live bait. Their adaptability is what makes them shine across all seasons and water types.
Best jig styles: ball head, stand-up, and swim jigs
Okay, let’s break it down a bit. Ball head jigs are my go-to. Super versatile and great for vertical jigging or slow hopping along the bottom structure. If I had to choose just one style forever, it’d be that.
Stand-up jigs are clutch when I’m fishing rocky bottoms. They keep your bait upright, which honestly makes it look way more natural. I started using them more when I realized I was not getting strikes because my bait was laying flat on the rock, and Walley don’t like banging their face into rocks.
Swim jigs are the ticket when walleyes are chasing baitfish, especially in warmer water. I’ll throw a paddle-tail plastic on the back and swim it through weed lines or over sand flats. It’s more of a power-fishing style, but it can trigger some savage hits when they’re aggressive.
Tips for jigging in cold vs warm water
Cold water jigging? Slow it way down. Like, painfully slow. When I’m fishing in 40°F water, I’m barely lifting that jig off the bottom, just dragging and pausing. Walleye don’t wanna chase anything when they’re half frozen.
Now, in warm water—say above 60°F—they’re a different beast. I’ll pop the jig more aggressively, sometimes even snap-jigging off the bottom. That erratic action mimics baitfish trying to flee, and walleye just can’t ignore it. I’ve had more than one surprise hook-up right after a hard snap off a rock pile.
Ideal soft plastics or live bait to pair with
Live bait is always a safe bet. Fathead minnows in spring? Killer. Leeches on a hot summer day? Absolute gold. I usually run live bait when the bite is tough—like early spring cold fronts or mid-summer doldrums.
Soft plastics, though, have really won me over. Paddle tails like the Keitech Easy Shiner or Berkley Ripple Shad are great for swim jigs. If I’m vertical jigging, I love something like a split-tail or fluke-style bait that glides on the fall. And don’t overlook Gulp! Alive minnows—those suckers have saved the day more than once when I couldn’t get live bait.
So yeah, jigs may not be flashy, but they flat-out produce. It took me a few seasons (and way too many lure purchases) to figure out I didn’t need to reinvent the wheel. If you’re just getting into walleye fishing—or if you’ve been at it for years—don’t underestimate the power of a well-worked jig. It’s the classic for a reason.
Crankbaits – Covering Water Fast
Crankbaits are what I reach for when I wanna find fish fast. They’re like the search dogs of the walleye world—cast or troll them around, and they’ll sniff out active fish quickly. I used to be super intimidated by crankbaits, especially when it came to trolling. So many shapes, sizes, diving depths—it felt like I needed a PhD just to figure out what to tie on. But once I started experimenting and learning how to read the water better, I realized crankbaits are actually one of the easiest ways to trigger aggressive strikes, especially when walleyes are on the move.
Top crankbait brands for walleye: Rapala, Berkley, etc.
If you’ve ever been to a bait shop and stared at the crankbait wall, you know it’s overwhelming. But there are a few tried-and-true brands that always get the job done for me. Rapala is a classic. The Shad Rap and the Husky Jerk are absolute killers in spring and fall. That tight wobble seems to really drive walleyes nuts in colder water.
Berkley’s Flicker Shad and Flicker Minnow are two of my all-time favorites for trolling. They track straight, dive consistently, and you can get them for cheap in multi-packs (which helps when you snag one on a stump and have to donate it to the lake gods).
Other solid options? Reef Runner for deep trolling and Salmo Hornets when I want more of a wide wobble. I don’t buy based on hype anymore—if it’s caught me fish more than once, it earns a permanent spot in the box.
When to troll vs casting crankbaits
Here’s how I break it down: I troll when I want to cover a lot of water or fish suspended walleyes. Early summer and fall are prime times. I’ll pull cranks along contour lines, flats, and break lines—anywhere I suspect fish are scattered.
Casting crankbaits works better when fish are pinned to structure. Like shallow rock piles, weed edges, or shoreline transitions. One time, I was working a wind-blown point with a #5 Shad Rap and caught six walleye in about 15 minutes. If I’d been trolling, I might’ve missed that tight school.
So, really use casting when you’ve found a spot worth picking apart and trolling when you’re still in search mode.
Best depth ranges and diving profiles
Crankbait depth matters a lot. I keep a crankbait dive chart printed and laminated in my boat—it’s saved me tons of guesswork. As a rule of thumb, I want my bait running just above the fish. Walleyes will come up to smash something, but rarely down.
For shallow water (5–10 ft), I love the Rapala Original Floater or the Berkley Flicker Shad #5. Mid-range (10–20 ft)? That’s where the Flicker Minnow #9 and Reef Runners come in. And for the deep haunts—like August fish hanging in 25+ feet—I’ll use snap weights to get those lures down deep without needing deep-diving baits.
Seasonal color patterns that attract strikes
Color is one of those things I used to obsess over way too much. But over time, I’ve noticed some reliable patterns based on the season and water clarity. In spring, when the water’s cold and often murky from runoff, I reach for brighter colors—firetiger, chartreuse, orange belly stuff. Walleyes are hungry, and visibility’s low, so I give them something they can’t miss.
Summer, especially in clear water, is all about natural hues. Chrome/blue, perch, and shad patterns dominate my spread. I’ve even caught a few on ghost patterns when the sun’s high and the water’s like glass. Fall brings me back to aggressive colors—purple, black/gold, and anything with a bit of red or orange belly.
I still carry too many colors, I’ll admit it. But after enough time on the water, you start to notice trends. When in doubt, match the hatch—or go bright when things get dirty.
Crankbaits aren’t magic, but they’re close. Once you get a feel for the diving depths and what kind of wobble works in different conditions, you’ll start trusting them more. And when that rod tip loads up while you’re trolling at 2.1 mph? Oh man… it never gets old.
Spinner Rigs – Deadly for Drifting and Trolling
I’ll be honest—spinner rigs didn’t impress me much when I first saw ’em. Just some beads and a blade on a wire with a crawler? Seemed too simple to be deadly. But then I fished a weed edge in mid-June, pulled a spinner rig with a half-crawler along the edge at 1.3 mph, and bam—three keeper walleye in under 10 minutes. I’ve been a believer ever since.
These things flat-out produce, especially when you want to cover water and give the fish something with flash, vibration, and scent. They’re especially killer in stained water and during summer when walleyes are on the move.
Components: blades, beads, hooks
Let’s break down the anatomy real quick. A typical spinner rig has a clevis-mounted blade up front, a string of colored beads, and one or two snelled hooks. The blade is what does all the work—creating flash and thump to draw attention. Beads? They’re not just for color. They act as spacers to keep the blade spinning cleanly without tangling on the hook.
Hooks vary based on bait. I usually go with a single hook for leeches or minnows and a two-hook crawler harness when I’m running nightcrawlers. I’ve tried tying my own rigs, too, which is weirdly therapeutic. Plus, you can mess with bead combos like orange/white or glow green, which don’t always come pre-packaged.
Ideal bait pairings: crawlers, minnows, leeches
If you haven’t pulled a full crawler behind a spinner rig, especially in warm water, you’re seriously missing out. That slow wiggle behind a thumping blade is like filet mignon for summertime walleyes. In cooler water or early spring, I’ll switch to minnows—usually fatheads or small chubs. They work great when walleyes are sluggish but still curious.
Leeches are underrated here. I usually slip on a medium-sized leech with a single hook and drift along shallow breaks or weed edges. That combo has saved more than one slow morning for me. A big tip: keep your bait lively. Dead bait = dead results.
How to fish spinners in weedy or rocky zones
Now, fishing spinner rigs around weeds or rocks? That takes some finesse. I’ve learned (the hard way) not to run my rigs too low in weedy areas. If your blade’s constantly dragging through salad, you’re not fishing effectively. I use a bottom bouncer or a bullet sinker to keep my rig just above the vegetation—usually about a foot off bottom.
In rocky areas, it’s all about slow and steady. Too fast, and you’re gonna hang up every few feet. I usually bump along at 1–1.2 mph, lifting the rig ever so slightly when I feel contact. Trust me, you’ll start to feel the difference between rocks and bites with time. A sensitive rod and a smooth drag are your best friends here.
Blade types (Colorado vs Willow) and when to use each
Blade selection is where you can get really dialed in. Colorado blades are my go-to for dirty water and low light—they kick out a ton of vibration and slow the whole rig down. That wide thump draws fish from a distance. I’ve caught a lot of mid-summer walleyes in stained lakes with a gold Colorado blade and orange beads.
Willow blades, on the other hand, spin tighter and faster. I use them in clear water or when I want to troll a little quicker, like 1.5–2.0 mph. They also track better in heavy current. There’s also Indiana blades—kind of a hybrid—but I honestly stick to Colorado and Willow for 90% of my setups.
One last thing—don’t be afraid to experiment with blade color. Chartreuse, firetiger, and silver are staples, but sometimes a black blade with a red dot just lights ’em up for no reason. Walleyes are weird like that.
Spinner rigs might not look flashy, but man, they work. Especially when you take the time to dial in your components, blade type, and bait presentation. It’s one of those techniques that lets you cover water and fish with finesse—and that combo’s hard to beat.
Soft Plastic Swimbaits – Realistic and Versatile
Swimbaits have honestly become one of my favorite tools in the walleye kit. There’s just something about the way they mimic real baitfish that feels… unfair, almost. I still remember the first time I tossed a 3.8″ paddletail into a shallow bay one cloudy spring morning. I slow-rolled it past some emerging cabbage, and wham—a fat 24-inch walleye smoked it so hard I thought I snagged a log. That moment changed how I fish during the entire post-spawn period.
They’re crazy versatile. You can fish ’em shallow, deep, fast, slow, solo, or as trailers. And when you “match the hatch,” just right? Game over.
Matching the hatch with lifelike profiles
I used to just grab any ol’ swimbait and chuck it, not really thinking about what the fish were feeding on. Big mistake. Once I started paying attention to the forage in each lake—like shiners, perch, or small gills—my hook-up ratio shot through the roof.
If you’re fishing a lake with smelt or shiners, go with slimmer baitfish profiles like the Keitech Easy Shiner or Berkley Power Swimmer. In places with young-of-year perch? I’ll use baits with vertical barring or that have a bit more bulk, like a 4″ Rage Swimmer in green pumpkin with chartreuse accents.
Pay attention to tail action, too. Some swimbaits thump hard, while others have a more subtle shimmy. Walleye can get picky.
Best jig head pairings for bottom bouncing
Jig heads make or break a swimbait’s performance. I learned that lesson quickly after trying to bounce a 1/8 oz round jig head in 18 feet of water—it just looked lifeless. These days, I match the weight to depth and current.
For bottom bouncing in deeper water (15–25 ft), a 3/8 oz ball head or football jig is perfect. Football jigs give you a nice flat presentation, especially over rock or gravel. In shallower or slower water, I go as light as 1/8 oz to keep the bait natural.
Use a jig head with a wire keeper if you’re tired of gluing baits or watching them slide down after every fish. Trust me, it saves time and sanity.
Retrieval techniques: slow roll, hopping, dragging
The beauty of swimbaits is that they look good with just about any retrieve—if you know when to use each. My go-to is the slow roll: cast it out, count it down, and retrieve just fast enough to make that tail wag. I use this when fish are suspended or feeding mid-column.
If the bite’s tougher or they’re glued to the bottom, I’ll hop it like a jig—lift it, let it fall, pause, repeat. That flutter on the fall triggers reaction strikes. And when water temps are cold or fish are super sluggish? Drag it. No hops, no flash—just a slow, steady creep along bottom. It’s boring… but it works.
Keep that rod tip low and stay in contact with the bait. Most bites feel like a faint “tick” or sudden weight. Set the hook like you mean it.
Top colors for murky vs clear water
Color matters more than I used to admit. In murky water, go bold: chartreuse, white, firetiger, or pink. One of my weirdly best-producing combos is a bright chartreuse body with a white tail—walleye seem to track it even in low vis.
In clear water, I tone it way down. Think natural: smelt, silver, translucent shad, or perch patterns. I’ve had great luck with a “bluegill flash” color in crystal-clear lakes, especially on sunny days. Early morning or cloudy? I’ll lean towards darker backs like green pumpkin or black to cast more of a silhouette.
Oh—and don’t be afraid to experiment. Some of my best days came from throwing an ugly brown bait I almost left at home.
Swimbaits aren’t just a bass thing anymore. When you dial in your size, color, and retrieval to match the conditions, they can absolutely clean up on walleye. Plus, they’re just fun to fish—there’s something about watching a bait that looks that real get inhaled by a big ol’ marble-eye.
Spoons – Flash and Vibration That Triggers Strikes
Spoons are kinda like that old friend you forgot about—until you run into them again and wonder why you ever lost touch. I didn’t start using spoons seriously for walleye until a buddy dragged me out on a frozen lake one winter. He dropped a little silver Swedish Pimple down the hole, jigged twice, and BAM—walleye on. I was stunned. There I was, fussing with tiny jigs and minnows while he was flat-out slayin’ with metal.
Since then, spoons have earned a permanent spot in my tackle box. Open water or ice, cold fronts or sunny skies—they just work, especially when walleye are moody.
When to use spoons (cold water, ice fishing, vertical jigging)
Spoons really shine in cold water. I’m talking late fall, early spring, or hard water season. That flutter and flash imitate a dying baitfish, which apparently triggers some primal instinct in walleye—like, “Oh hey, that looks easy to kill.”
Vertical jigging spoons is money when fish are stacked below you. I use a Vexilar or Garmin Livescope to drop right on ’em. Ice fishing is the obvious play, but don’t sleep on open-water vertical jigging in late fall. I’ve crushed ’em in 30 feet of water just hovering over a pod and jigging a Rattlin’ Buck-Shot.
And when they’re hanging mid-column and not hugging the bottom? A slower flutter spoon like a PK Spoon or Slender Spoon can hang in their face longer and coax a bite.
Key benefits: long casts, flutter action, flash
One of the best things about spoons is how far you can chuck ’em. They’re aerodynamic little missiles, perfect for covering a ton of water when fish are scattered. I’ll use a long rod and braid for extra distance, especially when casting from shore in spring or fall.
The flash? Unreal. Especially in stained water or low light. I’ve had walleye come in from 10 feet away just to swipe at the thing. And the vibration on the fall—whew. They can feel it through their lateral line, and sometimes, they’ll hit it before it even hits bottom.
Spoons also work great when you’re dealing with suspended fish that won’t commit to cranks or swimbaits. Drop it through the column and flutter it right in their strike zone.
Best sizes and finishes for walleye
For ice fishing, I like spoons in the 1/8 oz to 3/8 oz range. If I’m targeting eater-size fish (15-18 inch), something small like a Northland Forage Minnow Spoon in gold or glow works great. For bigger walleye or deeper water, I’ll go up to a 1/2 oz or heavier.
In open water, 1/4 oz to 3/4 oz is my usual range. Match the size to the depth and current. Heavier for deeper or faster water, lighter for shallow or slow.
Color-wise? Silver and gold are classics for a reason. I use silver in clear water or sunny days, gold in stained water or overcast conditions. Chartreuse, glow, and firetiger are also killer options, especially under ice or low light. Some of those UV patterns just pop.
How to avoid snags when spoon fishing
Snags used to drive me nuts when I started throwing spoons around rocks and timber. I lost more tackles than I care to admit. One tip that’s saved me a ton: control the fall. Don’t just let it free-fall and spiral into junk. Thumb the spool or keep tension on the line so it flutters more slowly and predictably.
Also, use single hooks if you’re fishing rocky or weedy areas. Treble hooks are great for open water or ice, but they’re a snag magnet near cover. Some brands let you swap them out easily—do it.
And when jigging vertically near structure, lift your rod slowly at first. If you feel anything weird—like resistance or a soft bump—pause and shake the spoon lightly instead of ripping it. A lot of times it’ll bounce free, and hey, sometimes that “snag” ends up being a lazy walleye.
Spoons aren’t just flashy hunks of metal—they’re precision tools when you learn how to use ’em right. Whether I’m on the ice or hovering over deep fall structure, they’ve bailed me out more than once when nothing else got bit. Sometimes, going old-school just plain works.
Blade Baits – A Vibration Machine
Blade baits are one of those lures that I didn’t fully “get” until I had one of those magical fall mornings where the fish were just dialed in. I remember the first time I really gave them a fair shake—I was on a deep break line in late October, marking fish on the bottom, and nothing was touching my jig or swimbait. Out of frustration, I tied on a silver SteelShad blade bait, dropped it straight down, and gave it a couple of little hops. Not five seconds later, I felt a solid thump—and boom, a chunky 25-inch walleye was in the net. I was hooked. Literally!
Why walleye love vibration in spring and fall
There’s something about the vibration that gets walleyes going, especially in cold water. In both spring and fall, their metabolism is slower, but their need to feed heavily ramps up—so they’re drawn to lures that mimic dying baitfish or give off strong signals they can detect easily through their lateral line. That’s where blade baits come in. They throw off a tight, hard thump every time you lift the rod tip, even with small movements.
During pre-spawn in spring or as temps dip again in fall, walleyes often stack on deep transitions—edges of river channels, gravel humps, or inside turns. And that consistent, tight vibration of a blade bait triggers them when flash alone doesn’t cut it. It’s like ringing the dinner bell.
Vertical jigging tactics for cold water
I mostly fish blade baits vertically when it’s cold. You don’t want to overdo it—short, controlled lifts are the key. Think of it more like a “tick” than a “rip.” I’ll lift the rod about 6 to 12 inches, feel that quick vibration, then let it fall on a semi-slack line. Most bites come on the drop, and you’ll either feel a thump or just dead weight when you go to lift again.
A big tip? Use braid with a fluoro leader. The braid helps you feel everything, which is huge when bites are subtle. Also, don’t be afraid to fish it slow. Sometimes, I’ll just drag it a few inches along the bottom, especially if the water’s under 40°F. If I’m on ice, I’ll use the same lift-drop rhythm right below the hole.
Top blade bait models that consistently produce
There are a few blades that have been rock-solid for me. The Silver Buddy is a classic—old-school but still deadly. The Johnson Thinfisher is another I always keep handy; it’s got a great flutter on the fall.
I also like the B Fish N Tackle B3 Blade because of its profile and weight options—it gets down fast and holds well in current. And if I want a smaller presentation, especially in spring rivers, the SteelShad Mini has been lights out. Go with natural silver, gold, or perch patterns for clear water, and brighter stuff like firetiger or chartreuse for stained or cloudy days.
Tips to avoid overworking the bait
If you take one thing from this section, let it be this: less is more. I’ve seen so many people fish blade baits like they’re burning crankbaits—fast, high lifts, constant movement. That’s not it. The key is subtle, deliberate motion. You want to feel that quick vibration buzz through the rod tip and then let it fall. Let it sit. Let the fish decide.
Also, don’t lift too high. If you’re yanking it two feet off the bottom, you’re likely pulling it out of the strike zone or just scaring skittish fish. Keep it low and slow—6- to 10-inch hops are usually plenty. In current, I sometimes just hold the blade steady and let it vibrate with the flow.
Blade baits aren’t the flashiest lures in the box, but they’re some of the most productive during the cold months. They’ve become my go-to when fish are hunkered down and picky. It’s not about flash or speed—it’s about feel. And once you get that subtle rhythm dialed in, they’re pure magic.
Minnows – A Time-Tested Live Bait Option
I’ve said it a hundred times on the boat—when in doubt, throw a minnow on. There’s just something about a struggling minnow that gets a walleye to commit when nothing else will. I’ve been fishing with minnows since I was barely tall enough to see over the edge of the bait bucket, and I still go back to them every season, especially in cold water or tough bite conditions. They just flat-out catch fish.
Live vs artificial minnows: pros and cons
Let’s talk about the real deal first—live minnows. They’ve got the scent, the flash, and that erratic wiggle that artificial baits just can’t copy 100%. When the bite is finicky, especially in early spring or late fall, I always start with live bait. There’s just no substitute when you’re trying to trigger inactive fish. Check your regulations for the area you are fishing. Some States and Provinces may not allow live minnows.
But live minnows do come with downsides. They’re fragile, need care, and—depending on local regulations—you might not be allowed to use them everywhere. Plus, keeping them alive on multi-day trips can be a hassle unless you’ve got a proper bait tank setup.
Artificial minnows like the Berkley Gulp! Alive Minnow or the Z-Man MinnowZ are solid backups. I’ve had days where the Gulp outfished live minnows, especially when fish were aggressive and hitting hard. Plastics hold up better in current, and you don’t have to worry about constantly rebaiting. They also last forever in your tackle bag and won’t stink up your truck.
Hooking techniques to keep minnows lively
The way you hook your minnow can seriously make or break your presentation. If I’m using a slip bobber or drifting slowly, I usually go through the back—right behind the dorsal fin. It lets the minnow swim naturally and stay alive longer.
If I’m jigging, I like to thread the hook through the mouth and out the top of the head. It keeps the bait on securely and gives the jig a more streamlined movement. One trick I picked up over time is using a thinner wire hook—like a size 6 or 4. It holds the minnow without doing too much damage and lets it keep that wiggle that drives fish nuts.
Best rigs for minnow presentation: slip bobber, Lindy, jighead
My top three rigs for minnows are hands-down: the slip bobber, Lindy rig, and jighead combo. The slip bobber is killer for still or slow-moving water, especially when fish are holding at a specific depth. You can hover a minnow right in their face and just wait for the bobber to go under.
The Lindy rig is my go-to for covering ground with a minnow. A light walking sinker, swivel, a few feet of leader, and a size 4 hook—it’s simple, and it works. I’ve dragged this setup through rocky points, across sandbars, and along weed lines, and it consistently puts fish in the net.
And, of course, the jighead—probably the most versatile tool in the walleye world. Tip a 1/8 oz jig with a fathead or rainbow, and you’re in business. Just remember to match the jig weight to your depth and drift speed. Too heavy and you’ll kill the action; too light and you’ll never reach the bottom.
Storage and care for long-lasting bait
If there’s one lesson I’ve learned the hard way, it’s to take minnow care seriously. I’ve had entire bait buckets go belly-up overnight just from bad water or a lack of oxygen. Now, I always carry a battery-powered aerator—it’s a game changer. Even a cheap $10 model will keep your bait lively all day.
Use a cooler or insulated bait bucket if you’re out on a hot day. Minnows don’t like warm water, and a sudden temp spike can shock them fast. Change the water out if it gets cloudy, and don’t overcrowd them—20 or 30 in a gallon is pushing it.
Also, keep them in water from the bait shop if possible. If you do switch to lake water, do it gradually to avoid shocking the minnows. A bit of patience here saves you from tossing out half your bait two hours into the trip.
Minnows aren’t glamorous, and they’re not always easy, but man, do they work. Whether you’re jigging a riverbank or bobber-fishing a drop-off, they’ve earned their place in the walleye playbook. When all else fails? Minnow up.
Leeches and Nightcrawlers – Deadly Natural Baits
If I had a nickel for every walleye I’ve caught on a leech or a nightcrawler, I could probably buy a new Lund boat. These baits are old-school, simple, and crazy effective—especially in summer when the fish get a little picky. There’s just something about the natural movement of a live leech curling in the current or a fat crawler undulating on a harness that triggers bites when artificial lures get ignored.
Why leeches are summer gold for walleye
Mid-summer? You’ll catch me reaching for leeches almost every time. Walleye go nuts for them when the water warms up. I don’t know if it’s the natural scent or that mesmerizing ribbon-like swim they do, but they work like a charm.
I’ve had days in July where nothing else got touched—not jigs, not cranks—but a jumbo leech under a slip bobber? Game on. It’s not uncommon to limit out in an hour when they’re really chewing. I like to target points and humps in 12–18 feet of water where walleye school up during those long, hot afternoons.
Medium to large leeches work best, and don’t overdo the hook size—something like a #6 or #4 octopus hook is perfect. Too big, and the leech won’t swim right, or worse, it’ll ball up and kill the action.
Proper rigging for live crawlers
Nightcrawlers are a whole different animal—well, technically still a worm—but their rigging makes a big difference. I used to just thread them onto a jig like spaghetti, and yeah, I’d catch a few. But when I learned to nose-hook them or use a crawler harness with spaced-out hooks? My hook-up ratio tripled.
If you’re going for a finesse bite, especially in clear water or with pressured fish, try just threading the crawler lightly through the nose with a single hook. It gives it a super natural look and lets it wiggle freely in the water.
For trolling or drifting, I love using harnesses with two hooks—one in the head, one halfway down the body. That way, short-strikers still get stuck. Oh, and always keep the crawler stretched out just a bit—not too tight, but not all bunched up. That long profile seems to call walleye in from a distance.
Trolling crawler harnesses for structure fishing
Trolling harnesses along breaks and drop-offs is like setting out a buffet line for walleyes. I usually run them behind a bottom bouncer in the 1.0–1.5 mph range. That slow roll lets the spinner blade flash and thump while the crawler does its thing.
Structure fishing with harnesses is all about staying close to the bottom without snagging every five seconds. I use a 1- to 2-ounce bottom bouncer depending on depth and current, and I’ll adjust line out to keep it just ticking bottom. Once you start feeling that “thump…thump…tick,” you know you’re in the zone.
One summer on Lake Erie, I watched four guys in another boat skunked for hours while we filled the livewell with nothing but gold blades, chartreuse beads, and fat Canadian crawlers. Lesson learned: don’t underestimate the power of scent and flash in combination.
Tips for storing and handling live bait
Leeches and crawlers are both a little high maintenance, but it’s worth it. For leeches, keep them in cool, clean water—preferably lake water or cold tap water, changed daily. I store mine in a small cooler with an ice pack wrapped in a towel so the leeches don’t get shocked. They’ll last weeks that way.
Crawlers are even pickier. I keep them in worm bedding or damp newspaper in a styrofoam container inside a fridge or cooler. Too warm, and they’ll turn into mushy soup. Too wet, and they’ll drown—yes, worms can drown. Weird, right?
Also, always handle them gently with wet fingers. Dry hands will suck the moisture right out of their skin, and once they start drying out, it’s downhill fast. If they get dirty or slimy, rinse them with cold water and let them chill for a bit. A healthy, wiggly crawler is a confident crawler—and that means more bites.
So yeah, they’re a little fussy, but when you see that rod tip bounce, your heart jumps? You’ll be glad you took the time. Leeches and crawlers have earned their stripes. They might not be flashy, but they’re absolute killers for summer walleye.
Bonus Tips: Matching Lures to Conditions
If there’s one thing walleye fishing has taught me over the years, it’s that the conditions can flip everything on its head. The same lure that was hot yesterday might be totally dead today—and yeah, it’s frustrating. But once I started matching my lure choice to specific weather patterns, times of day, and water conditions, my catch rate shot up like crazy.
Weather-based lure selection
Let’s start with the weather—because it seriously matters. On bright, sunny days with no clouds in sight, I’ve found subtle is better. Think natural colors, smaller profiles, slower action. Walleye can get skittish when the sun’s beating down, especially in clear water. I’ll reach for a live bait rig or a soft plastic in a muted shad or pumpkinseed tone.
Now, when clouds roll in, or a low-pressure system sets up, that’s when I bring out the big guns. Crankbaits with rattles, spinner rigs with chartreuse blades, even noisy blade baits—they all tend to shine when the sky’s dark and moody. It’s like the fish let their guard down a bit and start feeding more aggressively.
And right before a storm? Man, that bite window can be wild. I’ve had 30-fish mornings when I hit the lake ahead of a front, tossing perch-pattern cranks like I was in a bass tournament. But after the front moves through? Total shutdown. That’s when I downsize and slow things way, way down.
Day vs night tactics
Fishing at night? Totally different game. During the day, I rely on visibility, color, and flash. At night, it’s all about silhouette and vibration. I’ve had nights where a black jointed Rapala outfished everything else by a mile. Why black? It creates the strongest silhouette against the moonlit water—go figure.
Slow, steady retrieves work best after dark. Walleye are active but cautious, and they’ll follow a bait for a long time before striking. Glow-in-the-dark jig heads or UV-enhanced crankbaits can be clutch, too. Always keep a headlamp handy—not just for tying knots, but to check the bait, and bring a UV flashlight to refresh glow every so often.
How wind and current influence bait behavior
Wind can either ruin your drift or make it perfect—depending on how you play it. A good “walleye chop” stirs up baitfish and breaks up light penetration, giving predators the edge. That’s when I like to fish more aggressively. A spinner rig with a thumping Colorado blade really comes alive when there’s a bit of wave action.
In current-heavy spots like river mouths or tail races, I lean on vertical presentations. Blade baits, heavy jigs, and jigging spoons stay in the strike zone better and mimic disoriented baitfish. One mistake I made early on was not adjusting for how fast my bait was moving through the water column. You’ve gotta match the flow—sometimes even adding a stinger hook if short strikes become an issue.
Also, always pay attention to how wind and current combine. They can either push your boat into productive lanes or totally screw your control. A drift sock or trolling motor adjustments can mean the difference between just dragging bottom and staying right in the strike zone.
Adjusting lure size and color based on activity level
Matching lure size to walleye activity is something I used to overlook. On days when the fish were neutral or just not in the mood, I’d still throw my big, flashy favorites and wonder why I wasn’t getting hit. Eventually, I started thinking more like a fish. When they’re in a negative or neutral feeding state, downsizing makes a huge difference.
A 3-inch soft plastic on a light jig can look way more appetizing than a clunky 5-inch swimbait when the fish are feeling sluggish. And when they’re really turned on? I don’t hesitate to throw a full 5- to 6-inch crawler on a two-hook harness or a size 7 Flicker Shad to cover more water and attract the big girls.
Color-wise, I keep three categories: natural, bright, and dark. Natural gets the nod in clear water or high sun. Bright—like firetiger or pink lemonade—works when the water’s stained or the sky’s overcast. And dark, especially purples or blacks, gets tied on when the visibility drops way down or I’m fishing late evening.
Bottom line? There’s no magic lure—just the right lure for right now. Pay attention to the clues: weather, light, water clarity, fish mood. It takes some trial and error, and yeah, I’ve been stubborn and paid the price. But when you finally crack the code and start hooking up regularly? Man, there’s nothing like it.
Mastering Walleye with the Right Bait Strategy
There you have it—11 of the best walleye baits and lures that have proven themselves time and again. Whether you’re casting in spring, trolling in summer, or jigging through the ice in winter, having the right lure can make all the difference.
Remember: the best anglers adapt. Match your lure to the conditions, pay attention to water clarity, and, most importantly—have fun out there. Tight lines, and don’t forget to experiment to see what the walleyes are biting on today!
FAQ Section
Q: What is the absolute best bait for catching walleye?
A: There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but live minnows and jigs are widely considered top choices due to their versatility and effectiveness across seasons.
Q: What color lures work best for walleye?
A: In clear water, natural tones like silver, white, and perch patterns work best. In murky water or low light, chartreuse, glow colors, and firetiger are more effective.
Q: When is the best time of day to fish for walleye?
A: Early morning and dusk are prime feeding times. Walleye are low-light feeders, so low visibility hours are usually the most productive.
Q: Should I use live bait or artificial lures for walleye?
A: Both work well! Live bait (like minnows, leeches, and crawlers) is ideal for finicky fish, while artificial lures offer more versatility for covering water and triggering reaction strikes.
Q: How fast should I retrieve my lure when targeting walleye?
A: Walleye typically respond best to a slow and steady retrieve, especially in cold water or during low-light conditions. However, in warmer months or when using crankbaits and spinners, varying your retrieve speed with occasional pauses or twitches can trigger more aggressive strikes. Always adjust based on water temperature, fish activity, and lure type.
